Why Expensive Oil Is a Waste of Money

July 27, 2018

The company Blackstone Labs uses the motor oil contents to figure out the aging of an engine with time. It was only earlier in October that the Blackstone Labs dug into the massive database of analyses regarding used oil. This was a part of a study which was being conducted to find out if any of the oil brands contains large amounts of metal wear particles.

The Study

It was quite shocking to see the results that were unveiled. If anything, it will make racers think twice before opting for performance racing oils for their cars. The company receives thousands of oil samples from around the country. These are from people who are interested in finding out about their engines wearing off. This is important if you want to keep the engine healthy or take preventive measures before a certain catastrophic damage takes place.

For example, if you send in an oil sample, Blackstone Labs will analyze it and get back to you with a possible issue that may be affecting your automobile’s engine. If you fail to address that particular fault, it would lead to potential damage.

The Process

Blackstone Labs actually runs these samples through a spectrometer. This tells them how many parts per million are composed of wear elements like chromium from piston rings, aluminum from engine case and iron from cylinders, etc. In other words, the company has more than thousands of reports that show how a certain oil has affected a certain engine. This July, the company decided to compare different oil brands to see how the most expensive ones rank against the cheaper ones. As per the results, spending on costly oils does not bring your engine any extra benefit.

The Derivatives

Travis Heffelfinger—a senior analyst of the Blackstone Lab—wrote that the additive contents in the oils don’t account for a lot of variation in the engine wearing time. He then went on to explain that normalizing iron wear, the difference is quite minute across the board with the highest wear rate being 2.58 and the lowest being 2.03. In other words, the difference is negligible!

However, since we don’t know much about the weather condition and driving styles from the samples being received by the company, averaging samples based on their wear rate may not be the best solution.

Regardless of the limitations, it is pretty clear that even the cheapest of the oils in the market is doing a decent enough job to keep the engine in a well-maintained condition. The study discussed in this article cannot be deemed the most conclusive. There are various variables that need to be dealt with. Yet it is fair to say that companies that are selling their engine oils for a higher buck need to improve their quality; at least give the drivers something worth the money they are spending. As of now, cheaper oils like the ones from Walmart seem to be a good alternative to root for. At least until a conclusive study on this matter does not roll out.

Related posts

Japanese engines

Overheating Engines Part One: 3 Common Causes

There is no shortage of vehicles on today’s roads. This is especially true with a PwC forecast showing about 107 million vehicles will be manufactured globally in 2020 alone. And if you’re an owner of one of these vehicles, it’s important to be prepared for something to go wrong. After all, vehicles aren’t indestructible. In […]

used engines for sale

Overheating Engines Part Two: 5 Steps to Take

Engines can, unfortunately, be quite problematic. A common problem seen in the summer months is overheating — in the first part of this series, we talked a bit about some common causes of overheating in engines. Now, let’s talk about what you should do if you think your vehicle is overheating. Turn off the engine. if […]

used engines for sale

Tips On Getting The Best Used Car Engine

There are a number of reasons as to why you would like to buy a used car engine. First, you can get a used high quality engine at a lower price than a new engine. Second, it’s often cheaper to buy a new used engine rather than repairing the existing one. Of course, finding the […]